ISG Provider Lens™ Insurance Services – Strategic Capabilities Insurance GCC CaaS: Setup-Run-Optimize - Transform-Transfer - Global 2025

Incumbent insurance enterprises must leverage innovative GCC models to thrive amid economic challenges

The compelling value proposition

Amid economic volatility, ongoing inflation, talent shortage, technological changes and rising competition, incumbent insurance enterprises encounter unprecedented challenges that demand both cost optimization and capability growth. In this environment, providers offer models such as build-operatetransfer (BOT), build-own-operate-transfer (BOOT), build-operate-transform and transfer (BOTT), capability center as a service (CaaS) or global capability centers (GCCs) as distinctive solutions. These models represent structured approaches, delivering both short-term and operational gains alongside long-term strategic benefits, effectively addressing the complex, and sometimes conflicting, needs of insurers.

Addressing current critical business imperatives

Cost optimization without sacrificing capabilities: Insurance enterprises face ongoing pressure to cut expenses without compromising underwriting quality, claims service or CX. Traditional cost-cutting methods such as layoffs, renegotiating provider contracts and reducing discretionary spending, offer short-term benefits but can adversely impact operational efficiency and competitiveness. In contrast, models such as BOT/BOOT/BOTT/ CaaS GCC provide sustainable cost structures and substantial savings compared with similar onshore operations, while also boosting capabilities by giving access to specialized talent and use of advanced analytics and automation. Insurers see immediate financial benefits during the provider-managed phase and can achieve even larger long-term gains as captive operations develop after removing provider margins, post transfer.

Talent access amid severe shortages: The insurance industry in North America and Europe is experiencing a significant talent shortage in vital roles. Skilled professionals such as underwriters, claims adjusters, actuaries and tech specialists demand high salaries due to limited availability. Demographic shifts worsen these issues as retirements outpace the output from universities and training programs. In regions such as India, the Philippines, Poland and Latin America, where strong education systems, expanding insurance markets and favorable demographics ensure ample qualified candidates, models such as BOT/BOOT/BOTT offer quick access to large talent pools. Service providers utilize established recruitment channels, employer’s brand presence and existing talent pipelines to quickly build teams and strategies that established carriers otherwise struggle to implement when hiring independently in unfamiliar markets.

Speed and agility in uncertain environments: Economic uncertainties require organizations to be agile, adjust operations quickly, shift strategic priorities and respond promptly to market changes. Developing traditional captive or enterprise-owned/run GCCs takes 12-18 months and involves significant upfront investment, which can limit flexibility and lead to commitments before fully confirming business cases. In contrast, BOT/BOOT/ BOTT/CaaS models shorten timelines to three-six months and allow for validation during provider-managed phases before permanent captive investments. If market conditions change, business strategies evolve or offshore models underperform, carriers can better adapt by adjusting scope, relocating or changing approaches, — advantages that are rare with direct captive investments. This flexibility is especially valuable amid economic uncertainties and in short strategic planning periods.

Risk mitigation during volatile and uncertain social and political periods: Setting up an entity on foreign soils and establishing operations requires navigating complex regulatory environments, labor laws, pricing transfers and tax structures, as well as managing foreign exchange and geopolitical risks. During times of severe uncertainties such as trade tensions, regulatory shifts, pandemic disruptions or political unrest, these risks become further pronounced. Service providers take on the bulk of risks during the BOT/ BOOT/BOTT/CaaS phases by relying on local expertise, proven compliance systems and risk management strategies. This approach allow carriers to avoid direct exposure to employment liabilities, regulatory fines, facility commitments and geopolitical issues with the growth in operations. The transfer only happens after achieving sustainable success under stable conditions, thereby protecting the insurers from premature captive commitments that could become costly if the geopolitical environment worsens.

Enablement of technology modernization: Digital transformation remains a crucial strategy for staying competitive in the insurance industry. However, insurers often face challenges in allocating sufficient technology resources while managing legacy systems and meeting operational demands. BOT/BOOT/ BOTT/CaaS GCCs provide scalable access to technology talent, including software engineers, data engineers, QA specialists and DevOps professionals. These teams help accelerate modernization efforts, API development, cloud migrations, automation, and AI and ML model deployment. Their expertise in agile practices, modern development methods and advanced platforms complements the insurers domain knowledge, resulting in a powerful combination that boosts transformation speed. After the transfer, the insurers retain the personnel as permanent in-house resources.

How BOT/BOOT/BOTT/CaaS models add value

Immediate cost relief with strategic trajectory: Carriers realize cost savings as GCCs take over work previously done onshore or via high-cost outsourcing. After transfer, the removal of provider margins and management fees cuts costs by an additional 15-25 percent, compounding value. Unlike pure outsourcing, which offers static savings, BOT/BOOT/BOTT/ CaaS models increasingly improve economics with the development of captive operations, driving productivity, while automation lowers labor needs.

Secure path to strategic asset creation: Enterprise-owned or captive GCCs are key strategic assets offering ongoing cost savings, deep talent pools, innovation potential and operational agility that traditional outsourcing is unable to provide. Nonetheless, directly developing captives carries significant execution risks. Established carriers lack offshore operational know-how, underestimate complexities, misread market conditions or do not thoroughly plan implementations, which can lead to failed launches, performance problems or expensive corrective actions. Models such as BOT/BOOT/BOTT/CaaS utilize provider expertise to set up operations correctly from the start, allowing carriers to learn offshore management through partnerships instead of trial and error. Transfers take place only once operations are mature and consistently successful, significantly reducing the risks of execution.

Accelerated time to value: Every month of delay in establishing GCC operations results in missed savings, ongoing talent shortages and loss of competitive edge as peers advance their offshore initiatives. The compressed timelines of BOT/BOOT/BOTT/CaaS models, usually three-six months, from start to launch, allow carriers to realize benefits six months to a year sooner than direct captive models. In uncertain environments, where quick results are essential to secure ongoing investment and stakeholder trust, this acceleration is vital. Early wins foster momentum, validate offshore strategies and support organizational growth for broader GCC capabilities.

Flexibility to match market uncertainties: The current business environment requires operational flexibility such as rapid scaling of operations in response to volume changes, adapting cost structures to revenue fluctuations and pivoting strategies with market developments. BOT/BOOT/BOTT/CaaS agreements generally offer more favorable scaling options during provider-managed phases compared with permanent employment arrangements. This flexibility allows incumbent carriers to experiment with different operational models, process designs and automation strategies before committing to permanent solutions through transfer. Such flexibility is crucial for optimizing operations prior to taking full ownership. Moreover, a phased transfer, rather than one with a fixed schedule, aligns the process with favorable economic conditions, available capital and organizational readiness.

Knowledge transfer and capability building: In addition to operational services, BOT/BOOT/ BOTT/CaaS providers facilitate knowledge transfer, helping build internal carrier capabilities for long-term offshore success. This involves training their staff in offshore management, documenting operational processes, sharing talent management and retention best practices, offering guidance on regulatory compliance and risk management, and supporting organizational change initiatives. Carriers gain expertise that not only ensures successful GCC operations after transfer, but also supports potential expansion to new locations, capacities or business units by applying the lessons learned. This development of capabilities provides lasting value that extends far beyond individual GCC projects.

Enhanced organizational resilience: Recent disruptions, such as pandemic lockdowns, natural disasters, cyberattacks and supply chain failures, emphasize the critical need for operational resiliency and business continuity. Geographically dispersed GCCs ensure continuity of operations if primary sites face disruptions. Providers generally establish strong business continuity measures, including backup facilities, work-from-home setups, redundant infrastructure and well-documented, regularly tested procedures and transfer this resilient framework to existing carriers after the transition, strengthening overall enterprise risk management.

Access to innovation and emerging capabilities: Leading providers consistently invest in new technologies, operational improvements and capabilities to stay competitive in markets characterized by several players. Carriers gain access to their innovations such as automation platforms, AI tools, analytics and best practices, without incurring any upfront development expenses. Providers also encourage knowledge sharing among clients, including that on innovations and improvements, thereby surpassing what could be achieved only through internal development.

Financial structure optimization: BOT/BOOT/ BOTT/CaaS commercial models transform large CapEx into OpEx spread over time. This approach enhances cash flow management during uncertain periods and is often favored by carriers with limited capital, investor concerns or regulatory obligations requiring maintaining balance sheets. Also, performance-based fee structures link provider payments to operational outcomes, ensuring carriers pay for value created rather than effort and accrue the benefits of efficient risk distribution in uncertain times.

Competitive differentiation through strategic GCC development

As the insurance market becomes increasingly commoditized and technology makes traditional advantags more accessible, operational excellence becomes a key differentiator. Carriers that develop advanced GCC capabilities, merging cost efficiency, talent, innovative technologies and operational agility, can outperform competitors while enhancing policyholder experiences.

This powerful mix shifts competitive dynamics significantly. BOT/BOOT/BOTT/CaaS models enable carriers without offshore capabilities or with outdated legacy centers to quickly bridge gaps, match industry leaders and build a foundation for future advantages.

Furthermore, as insurtech startups, technologycentric digital insurers and neo-insurers embrace cloud-native architectures and leverage global talent, established insurance enterprises must modify their cost structures and operational models to remain competitive. BOT/BOOT/BOTT/CaaS models allow legacy firms to gradually transform their operations, thereby reducing the risks associated with sudden, large-scale changes that could impact business continuity.

These models, in short, help established carriers manage current uncertainties by hitting short-term financial goals, while developing long-term strategic assets. Doing this, helps the carriers maintain a competitive edge as markets stabilize and growth chances improve. In a time that demands both efficiency and innovation, as well as cost control and capability growth, BOT/BOOT/BOTT/CaaS approaches provide unique solutions that combine seemingly conflicting needs through well-structured partnerships and phased ownership changes.

Access to the full report requires a subscription to ISG Research. Please contact us for subscription inquiries.